A City Without People is not a City

A series of articles on China’s empty cities triggers a series of Integral City thought capsules and thought experiments.

China Ghost City , Photographed by Caemmerer

China Ghost City , Photographed by Caemmerer

According to a Wired article, China has built 100’s of cities to house millions of people over the next 20 years. Today they stand empty. No people in the apartments. No workers in the workplaces. No vehicles at the intersections. No eyes on the street.

The photographs of the cities are hauntingly dream-like – but they remind me of Burtinsky’s horrifyingly beautiful renditions of industrial pollution.

While America built houses with a sub-prime mortgage scheme that encouraged runaway development and entrapped ordinary workers with financial overheads that became intolerable and too onerous to bear, the state of China has invested in not just houses but whole built cities – now warehoused, waiting for inhabitants.

Which investment scheme has more merit? The one that sucks the breath out of people’s souls or the one that builds “brick lungs” without souls?

Integral City would argue that the built city of bricks and mortar is a container – but incomplete. When the design and purpose of the city container is built without the participation of the inhabitants, it lacks the native intelligences of Culture and Consciousness. It is an exoskeleton without soul.

The Chinese may have hired the best architects, but did they study the history of “housing projects” and people relocations elsewhere? Do they have plans to cope with the hopelessness, addictions and disorientation of the Inuit who were relocated in Canada? Or do they have expectations to cope with the inner city dis-ease and lawlessness that characterizes Toronto’s Regent’s Park or Chicago’s south side (where Jane Jacob’s predicted that the lack of “eyes on the street” would create conditions lacking safety and security). Or do they know how they will prevent the unemployment and clannish enclaves that became the Gorbals in Glasgow?

This is part of a series of blogs on China’s empty cities that triggered a series of Integral City thought capsules and thought experiments. See:

A City Without People is not a City 

Building a

About the Author:

HI I am the Founder of Integral City Meshworks Inc. and Chief Blogger. Working with cities and eco-regions, I ‘meshwork’ or weave people, purpose, priorities, profits, programs and processes to align contexts, grow capacity and develop strategies for sustainability and resilience in the Integral City. You can read more details about me here http://integralcity.com/about/about-the-founder/

5 Comments

  1. […] Previous […]

  2. […] A City Without People is not a City  […]

  3. […] hauntingly beautiful photographs by Caemerrer of China’s new – but empty – cities reminded me of Burtynsky’s photographs of industrial […]

  4. […] has a sense of humour. Otherwise, I might not notice that in one week I read an article on the Zombie Cities in China – where the human hive has been built without a human to occupy them (yet) … and […]

  5. […] A City Without People is not a City […]

Leave A Comment